I read this
fascinating article in The Wall Street Journal- best paper ever- over the weekend. It is an interesting view, certainly. Somewhat simplistic at times, but a very different opinion than the popular opinion of attachment parenting.
A friend of mine send me a message about this article, this is a dear friend of mine, who is thoughtful, smart, and basically, I want to be like her. I am quoting her directly.
"You know, nobody grates on me more than the attachment parenting crowd -- they are zealots and like to make people feel that the "research" shows their way is the best way etc. I am surrounded by them and all I see are exhausted, haggard women, bratty kids that think they are the center of the universe and a deep conviction that they are right. Well, don't they know that I am right? Ha ha....The other thing I thought about the article though is that no woman is being imprisoned. Prison is something that, once you are there, you can't get up and walk out. Each one of us is free to mother however we see fit for the well being of our children and ourselves. Anyone who is smashing their own organic peas and doesn't want to should just STOP! They can and they should exercise their free will and forget about what other people think. Ugh. The article almost victimizes women by not pointing out that we are strong, intelligent and free-- not imprisoned. There....that is what I dare not say on Facebook because I don't want to deal with the thread of conversation."
This is such a divisive topic, isn't it? My smart and thoughtful friend doesn't want to start a war on my facebook page. I love her! But I will start the war here, because I am provocative like that.
I have quite a few patients that come to me for lots of different reasons, but over the course of therapy, these young professional people essentially have to confront this question: "Do I want kids or not?" And they all like to know how I made my decision to have kids. (They assume I have kids, and when they ask, I do tell them I have kids. I mean, I can't deny that and then run into them at Costco with my brood!) This sweet, talented woman told me today about a study showing how single women are healthier than married women, whereas married men are healthier than single men. Her conclusion was that single women have the time/money to take care of themselves, whereas married men have their wives to take care of them. Can this be true? I came home and asked Hubby, he thought there are more ways to interpret it. For instance, married women really let themselves go... (Ha, ha.) Or, married men take good care of themselves because they are motivated to stay healthy to be with their families.
Another patient told me that he thinks parents totally just 'let themselves go, they get fat, they look ugly, and basically, miserable.' (Is that how he sees me?) Very kindly of him, however, he did say that he thought I was an exception. And he wanted to know my tricks.
It is very interesting for me to think about why I chose to have A&Z. They are so incredibly cute, but it is also hard. (For instance, I got a phone call from Aidan's school today that he missed his ride to his Chinese school. I got the voice mail at 7 pm, when we were all home already. Upon my investigation, he had 'missed' his ride because he talked too much at school today and was kept after class! Like I said, it is hard, and at times, troublesome.) Why did I do it? Twice? I believe in a way, I was out of my mind. I got brainwashed by Pottery Barn Kids catalogs. Have you seen how beautiful the catalog is? Chubby, clean, well-behaved children. Happy, glowing mothers reading to their children!
I will admit it, sometimes, when I am herding the turtles home, I daydream a bit. About my life if we were still without kids. I think I would work a lot more, I would be RICH, and I would probably be in really good shape physically. Hubby thinks we will be lonely, "with A&Z shaped holes in our hearts." I think he is right, as much as I don't want to agree with him.
From time to time, I will throw myself a pity party, "Woe is me, I work, I take care of A&Z, I cook, I clean, I do laundry. What does Hubby do? WTF?!" One thing that I love about my husband is that he is not petty. He doesn't keep records like this, he doesn't think about who is working harder. He just loves abundantly, generously, and kindly. You know how I ended up with the responsibilities of cooking, cleaning, laundering? Because I secretly like to take care of him, I like to be in charge of domestic duties. Until I am tired and worn out that is, then I give myself a pity party. If I were sitting with myself in a therapy session, I would tell myself that really doesn't make any logical sense at all.
And I think it is like that with the attachment parenting people. They like to say that they make their own organic compost to grow their organic carrots, which they steam (not microwave, I mean, the microwave kills!), until they are so tired and sick of it. Yet they like it. Like my friend said, they chose to put themselves in that position.
I tell my patients, You have a choice. You can choose to do attachment parenting and then want to die in the process, you can choose to not have kids and have a clean and orderly life. Or, you can choose to have kids, have some mess, feed them store bought organic baby food, let them cry it out, give them lots of kisses, time them out, give consequences. (Like a letter to a teacher, "Dear Ms.Z, I am sorry that I talked too much in class. I am sorry I wasn't listening. I am sorry that I made your job harder. Will you forgive me?")
It is about making choices.